Results of SurveyUSA Election Poll #14905
 
Just As It Did in So Many 2008 Contests, Black Turnout Will Decide Winner of LA4 House Race. In the December 4 stand-alone election to fill the open US House seat in Louisiana's 4th Congressional District, Republican John Fleming may or may not have a slight edge on Democrat Paul Carmouche, depending on how many of the district's African Americans vote, according to a SurveyUSA poll conducted for Roll Call, the newspaper of Capitol Hill. Fleming leads 2:1 among white voters. Carmouche leads 9:1 among black voters.

If blacks make up 27% of likely voters on December 4, as reported in the tables and charts that follow, the Republican leads 47% to 45%. For every percentage point that black turn-out is higher than 27%, the contest tips one point more to the Democrat. For every percentage point that black turn-out is lower than 27%, the contest tips one point more to the Republican. For example:

If black turn-out is 24%, it's Fleming 48%, Carmouche 43%.
If black turn-out is 30%, it's Carmouche 46%, Fleming 45%.

Turn-out in a stand-alone special election, where there are not other contests on the ballot to draw voters to the polls, is uniquely difficult to forecast. Fleming has a Plus 13 Favorability. Carmouche has a Plus 16 Favorability. Barack Obama has Net Zero Favorability. 44% approve of the job President Bush is doing. 14% approve of the job the US Congress is doing.

 
Filtering: 900 registered voters were interviewed by SurveyUSA 11/17/08 and 11/18/08, using Registration Based Sample (RBS) from Aristotle in Washington DC. Of the registered voters, 648 were determined by SurveyUSA to be likely to vote in the December 4 election.
 
1If the election for U.S. House of Representatives, were today, would you vote for ... (names rotated) Republican John Fleming? Democrat Paul Carmouche?
648 Likely VotersAllGenderAge<50 / 50+RaceParty AffiliationIdeologyOpinion Of ObamaOpinion Of FlemingOpinion Of CarmoucheBush Overall AppJob Performance Top Issue For CongressBetter Equipped Vote For US Hous
Credibility Interval: ± 3.9 pct pointsMaleFemale18-3435-4950-6465+18-4950+WhiteBlackHispanicAsian/OtRepublicDemocratIndependConservaModerateLiberalFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralApproveDisapproApproveDisapproEconomyEnvironmHealth CIraqTerrorisGasolineEducatioImmigratRepublicDemocratFlemingCarmouch
John Fleming (R)47%48%46%44%50%42%52%48%46%63%9%****82%17%45%73%24%8%9%83%50%91%3%24%11%87%66%79%17%30%53%41%**32%40%83%****79%81%7%100%0%
Paul Carmouche (D)45%41%47%45%41%50%41%43%47%28%85%****11%76%37%19%68%80%84%11%33%6%89%57%87%4%18%13%75%65%39%51%**62%49%9%****8%12%87%0%100%
Gerald Bowen, Jr. (I)1%2%1%2%1%1%1%1%1%1%1%****1%1%2%1%2%1%1%1%4%1%0%4%1%1%2%1%1%1%1%1%**1%5%0%****3%0%2%0%0%
Chester "Catfish" Kelley (I)3%6%1%3%5%3%1%4%2%3%2%****3%2%3%3%2%5%3%3%2%2%5%3%1%6%2%3%3%4%3%3%**0%0%6%****6%3%3%0%0%
Undecided4%3%5%6%3%4%5%4%4%4%2%****3%3%13%3%4%6%4%2%10%0%2%12%0%1%12%3%4%0%4%4%**4%6%2%****3%3%1%0%0%
Total100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Composition of Likely Voters100%45%55%19%30%31%21%48%52%68%27%1%5%41%46%11%52%30%12%42%42%14%44%31%20%44%28%23%44%48%14%74%59%1%6%5%11%3%4%6%52%42%47%45%
 
2Is your opinion of Barack Obama ... favorable? Unfavorable? Neutral? Or, do you have no opinion of Barack Obama?
648 Likely VotersAllGenderAge<50 / 50+RaceParty AffiliationIdeologyOpinion Of ObamaOpinion Of FlemingOpinion Of CarmoucheBush Overall AppJob Performance Top Issue For CongressBetter Equipped Vote For US Hous
Credibility Interval: ± 3.9 pct pointsMaleFemale18-3435-4950-6465+18-4950+WhiteBlackHispanicAsian/OtRepublicDemocratIndependConservaModerateLiberalFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralApproveDisapproApproveDisapproEconomyEnvironmHealth CIraqTerrorisGasolineEducatioImmigratRepublicDemocratFlemingCarmouch
Favorable42%39%44%50%40%42%38%44%40%21%92%****9%71%39%16%62%87%100%0%0%12%79%45%71%13%23%7%74%70%34%49%**53%48%10%****9%6%86%8%78%
Unfavorable42%46%39%37%45%42%42%42%42%57%6%****72%17%39%67%18%10%0%100%0%72%15%24%17%75%52%75%13%21%49%34%**37%34%75%****79%75%6%74%10%
Neutral14%13%15%12%12%14%17%12%16%19%2%****16%11%20%14%18%3%0%0%100%13%6%29%10%10%23%16%12%8%15%16%**10%18%13%****5%16%8%15%10%
No Opinion2%2%3%1%3%2%3%2%3%3%1%****3%2%2%3%2%1%0%0%0%3%1%3%1%2%3%3%1%1%2%2%**0%0%3%****7%3%0%3%1%
Total100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Composition of Likely Voters100%45%55%19%30%31%21%48%52%68%27%1%5%41%46%11%52%30%12%42%42%14%44%31%20%44%28%23%44%48%14%74%59%1%6%5%11%3%4%6%52%42%47%45%
 
3If your opinion of John Fleming is...
648 Likely VotersAllGenderAge<50 / 50+RaceParty AffiliationIdeologyOpinion Of ObamaOpinion Of FlemingOpinion Of CarmoucheBush Overall AppJob Performance Top Issue For CongressBetter Equipped Vote For US Hous
Credibility Interval: ± 3.9 pct pointsMaleFemale18-3435-4950-6465+18-4950+WhiteBlackHispanicAsian/OtRepublicDemocratIndependConservaModerateLiberalFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralApproveDisapproApproveDisapproEconomyEnvironmHealth CIraqTerrorisGasolineEducatioImmigratRepublicDemocratFlemingCarmouch
Favorable44%49%41%44%43%40%53%44%45%58%14%****72%21%42%68%21%12%12%77%41%100%0%0%17%79%58%75%18%32%50%39%**34%38%76%****68%75%11%86%6%
Unfavorable31%29%32%32%26%36%28%28%33%22%52%****11%48%26%14%45%62%58%11%13%0%100%0%57%11%9%10%52%51%27%35%**40%43%10%****9%10%57%2%61%
Neutral20%20%20%18%24%21%14%22%18%17%24%****15%24%23%15%28%18%21%11%41%0%0%100%22%9%29%13%25%13%20%21%**20%16%9%****23%13%25%10%25%
No Opinion5%2%8%6%7%3%5%6%4%3%10%****2%8%9%3%6%8%9%1%6%0%0%0%5%1%4%2%6%4%3%4%**7%2%5%****0%2%7%2%7%
Total100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Composition of Likely Voters100%45%55%19%30%31%21%48%52%68%27%1%5%41%46%11%52%30%12%42%42%14%44%31%20%44%28%23%44%48%14%74%59%1%6%5%11%3%4%6%52%42%47%45%
 
4If your opinion of Paul Carmouche is...
648 Likely VotersAllGenderAge<50 / 50+RaceParty AffiliationIdeologyOpinion Of ObamaOpinion Of FlemingOpinion Of CarmoucheBush Overall AppJob Performance Top Issue For CongressBetter Equipped Vote For US Hous
Credibility Interval: ± 3.9 pct pointsMaleFemale18-3435-4950-6465+18-4950+WhiteBlackHispanicAsian/OtRepublicDemocratIndependConservaModerateLiberalFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralApproveDisapproApproveDisapproEconomyEnvironmHealth CIraqTerrorisGasolineEducatioImmigratRepublicDemocratFlemingCarmouch
Favorable44%43%44%42%39%48%45%41%47%31%75%****17%70%35%24%61%71%75%18%33%17%82%48%100%0%0%19%69%68%39%50%**57%48%16%****13%17%77%10%86%
Unfavorable28%30%26%24%30%28%27%27%28%36%10%****48%13%20%42%14%12%9%50%19%49%10%12%0%100%0%45%13%16%32%24%**27%17%50%****36%47%7%51%3%
Neutral23%24%23%27%25%19%23%26%21%28%11%****30%14%35%29%21%11%13%29%37%30%7%34%0%0%100%31%14%11%26%23%**12%29%27%****48%29%13%33%9%
No Opinion5%3%7%7%6%4%4%6%4%5%4%****6%3%9%5%4%6%4%4%10%4%1%6%0%0%0%6%4%5%4%4%**4%5%8%****4%6%2%6%2%
Total100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Composition of Likely Voters100%45%55%19%30%31%21%48%52%68%27%1%5%41%46%11%52%30%12%42%42%14%44%31%20%44%28%23%44%48%14%74%59%1%6%5%11%3%4%6%52%42%47%45%
 
5Do you approve or disapprove of the job George W. Bush is doing as President?
648 Likely VotersAllGenderAge<50 / 50+RaceParty AffiliationIdeologyOpinion Of ObamaOpinion Of FlemingOpinion Of CarmoucheBush Overall AppJob Performance Top Issue For CongressBetter Equipped Vote For US Hous
Credibility Interval: ± 3.9 pct pointsMaleFemale18-3435-4950-6465+18-4950+WhiteBlackHispanicAsian/OtRepublicDemocratIndependConservaModerateLiberalFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralApproveDisapproApproveDisapproEconomyEnvironmHealth CIraqTerrorisGasolineEducatioImmigratRepublicDemocratFlemingCarmouch
Approve44%49%41%41%45%43%48%43%45%59%9%****74%20%41%68%23%11%7%79%49%74%14%29%19%71%58%100%0%35%48%36%**35%42%83%****63%76%9%75%13%
Disapprove48%44%52%55%44%51%45%48%49%34%84%****19%73%53%24%72%82%86%15%41%19%82%60%77%23%29%0%100%61%46%57%**58%56%14%****24%18%86%18%81%
Not Sure7%7%8%4%12%6%6%9%6%7%7%****7%7%6%8%5%7%7%6%10%7%4%11%5%6%13%0%0%4%6%7%**7%2%3%****13%6%5%8%6%
Total100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Composition of Likely Voters100%45%55%19%30%31%21%48%52%68%27%1%5%41%46%11%52%30%12%42%42%14%44%31%20%44%28%23%44%48%14%74%59%1%6%5%11%3%4%6%52%42%47%45%
 
6Do you approve? Or disapprove? Of the job the United States Congress is doing?
648 Likely VotersAllGenderAge<50 / 50+RaceParty AffiliationIdeologyOpinion Of ObamaOpinion Of FlemingOpinion Of CarmoucheBush Overall AppJob Performance Top Issue For CongressBetter Equipped Vote For US Hous
Credibility Interval: ± 3.5 pct pointsMaleFemale18-3435-4950-6465+18-4950+WhiteBlackHispanicAsian/OtRepublicDemocratIndependConservaModerateLiberalFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralApproveDisapproApproveDisapproEconomyEnvironmHealth CIraqTerrorisGasolineEducatioImmigratRepublicDemocratFlemingCarmouch
Approve14%14%13%15%14%13%14%14%13%13%16%****7%19%10%7%19%30%23%7%8%10%23%9%21%8%6%11%17%100%0%14%**9%15%4%****3%8%19%9%20%
Disapprove74%75%73%70%71%76%77%71%77%78%66%****85%64%78%85%66%53%60%86%80%83%65%73%65%84%82%81%70%0%100%73%**66%73%87%****88%85%62%84%64%
Not Sure13%11%14%15%15%11%9%15%10%9%18%****8%17%13%8%15%18%17%8%12%7%12%18%14%8%12%9%13%0%0%13%**25%12%9%****9%7%19%7%17%
Total100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Composition of Likely Voters100%45%55%19%30%31%21%48%52%68%27%1%5%41%46%11%52%30%12%42%42%14%44%31%20%44%28%23%44%48%14%74%59%1%6%5%11%3%4%6%52%42%47%45%
 
7Which one issue should congress focus on ahead of all others? (choices rotated) The economy? The environment? Health care? Iraq? Terrorism? The price of gasoline? Education? Immigration? Or some other issue?
630 Likely VotersAllGenderAge<50 / 50+RaceParty AffiliationIdeologyOpinion Of ObamaOpinion Of FlemingOpinion Of CarmoucheBush Overall AppJob Performance Top Issue For CongressBetter Equipped Vote For US Hous
Credibility Interval: ± 3.9 pct pointsMaleFemale18-3435-4950-6465+18-4950+WhiteBlackHispanicAsian/OtRepublicDemocratIndependConservaModerateLiberalFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralApproveDisapproApproveDisapproEconomyEnvironmHealth CIraqTerrorisGasolineEducatioImmigratRepublicDemocratFlemingCarmouch
Economy59%57%62%57%55%60%69%55%63%58%67%****54%66%56%54%65%69%69%47%67%52%70%64%68%52%57%48%71%65%59%100%**0%0%0%****0%51%70%52%69%
Environment1%1%1%2%1%1%1%1%1%1%1%****0%2%0%0%1%2%1%1%2%0%2%0%1%1%1%1%2%1%1%0%**0%0%0%****0%1%1%0%2%
Health Care6%7%6%9%5%7%4%6%6%5%8%****4%9%5%5%6%11%8%5%4%5%8%6%8%6%3%5%7%4%5%0%**100%0%0%****0%5%8%4%9%
Iraq5%5%5%5%8%5%2%7%4%5%5%****5%6%2%4%8%3%6%4%7%4%7%4%6%3%6%5%6%6%5%0%**0%100%0%****0%4%6%4%6%
Terrorism11%11%11%7%10%14%11%9%13%15%2%****18%4%12%18%5%0%3%19%10%19%4%5%4%20%12%20%3%4%13%0%**0%0%100%****0%18%3%19%2%
Gasoline3%4%2%4%3%2%1%4%2%2%4%****3%2%3%3%1%6%2%4%3%3%2%4%2%3%2%4%1%6%2%0%**0%0%0%****0%4%2%2%2%
Education4%3%5%6%4%3%3%5%3%3%6%****3%5%3%3%4%6%6%2%2%4%4%3%5%3%2%4%4%10%4%0%**0%0%0%****0%3%5%4%5%
Immigration6%7%5%6%8%5%6%7%5%8%2%****9%3%10%9%5%0%1%12%2%9%2%7%2%8%13%9%3%2%8%0%**0%0%0%****100%10%2%11%1%
Other2%3%1%1%3%2%2%2%2%2%1%****2%1%4%2%2%1%1%3%2%2%0%1%2%2%1%2%1%0%2%0%**0%0%0%****0%2%1%2%1%
Not Sure2%3%2%3%4%1%1%3%1%2%4%****1%3%5%2%2%1%3%2%1%2%1%5%3%2%3%2%1%3%1%0%**0%0%0%****0%2%3%2%3%
Total100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Composition of Likely Voters100%46%54%19%30%31%21%49%51%68%27%1%5%41%46%11%52%30%11%42%42%14%45%30%20%43%28%24%45%48%13%74%59%1%6%5%11%3%4%6%52%42%47%44%
 
8Which party do you think is best equipped to handle the economy? (choices rotated) The Republicans? Or The Democrats?
624 Likely VotersAllGenderAge<50 / 50+RaceParty AffiliationIdeologyOpinion Of ObamaOpinion Of FlemingOpinion Of CarmoucheBush Overall AppJob Performance Top Issue For CongressBetter Equipped Vote For US Hous
Credibility Interval: ± 4 pct pointsMaleFemale18-3435-4950-6465+18-4950+WhiteBlackHispanicAsian/OtRepublicDemocratIndependConservaModerateLiberalFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralFavorablUnfavoraNeutralApproveDisapproApproveDisapproEconomyEnvironmHealth CIraqTerrorisGasolineEducatioImmigratRepublicDemocratFlemingCarmouch
Republicans52%55%49%46%54%49%58%51%52%69%11%****87%20%53%81%23%9%8%91%60%86%17%34%21%87%64%87%19%33%59%44%**38%44%83%****85%100%0%88%14%
Democrats42%40%44%46%40%45%37%42%42%24%87%****9%75%29%14%69%85%87%6%24%10%80%53%76%11%24%8%76%61%35%49%**53%52%11%****12%0%100%6%83%
Not Sure6%5%7%8%6%6%5%7%6%7%2%****4%5%18%5%8%6%5%4%16%4%3%13%4%2%13%4%5%6%6%6%**9%4%6%****3%0%0%5%3%
Total100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%100%
Composition of Likely Voters100%45%55%19%30%31%21%48%52%68%27%1%5%42%46%11%53%30%11%42%43%14%45%30%20%43%28%24%45%48%13%74%59%1%6%5%11%3%4%6%52%42%48%44%
 
** Too few respondents of this type were interviewed for this data to be meaningful.